The McClure Handcrafted Shuffleboard Table Difference
Introduction
At McClure Tables, we focus on materials and craftsmanship above all else.
We build our tables in Michigan using locally sourced hard maple and sell directly to customers — allowing more of your investment to go into the product itself.
💡 Did you know
Shuffleboard tables can appear similar online, but construction details vary significantly.
Understanding materials and specifications helps you compare tables more accurately.
Selecting the Best Shuffleboard Table
Understanding Playboard Materials
Different manufacturers use different hardwood species for their playboards. While many tables may appear similar online, the type of wood used, along with how thickness is measured, can affect durability, long-term stability, and overall playing experience
European Beech: commonly used by some domestic brands. Beech has a Janka hardness of around 1,300 and offers good durability.
Soft Maple
Often marketed as “Canadian Maple.” With a Janka hardness between 700 and 950, it is softer than hard rock maple and may dent more easily over time.
Birch (Imported)
Birch is widely used in imported butcher block tops. While technically a hardwood, it is less dense than hard maple and may be more susceptible to impact wear.
North American Hard Rock Maple
With a Janka hardness of around 1,450, hard rock maple is considered by many to be the traditional standard for high-end shuffleboard tables due to its density, durability, and consistent grain structure.
😍Expert Tip:
When comparing tables, look closely at how board thickness is measured.
Some specifications include the Polymer surface coating, usually 1/4" thick in the total measurement, while traditional finish boards refer to the wood thickness alone.
This helps you compare tables more accurately.
Pros Cons of Traditional Finish over Polymer Board
The Authentic Experience: Hard Rock Maple. North American hard rock maple (Sugar Maple) is widely regarded as the "gold standard" for premium shuffleboard tables due to its unique properties:
- Density and Durability: With a Janka hardness of around 1,450 lbf, it is extremely dense and highly resistant to the dents and "dimples" caused by dropped pucks.
- Performance: The natural smoothness and density of the wood provide a fast, predictable, and consistent glide for the pucks.
- Legacy: Hard maple was the wood of choice for mid-20th-century antique tables still in use today, solidifying its place in shuffleboard history.
The Finish Debate: Polyester vs. Polymer. While all quality tables require a durable finish, there are two main schools of thought regarding the top coat:
-
Traditional Polyester Finish: High-end, American-made manufacturers like McClure Tables advocate for a "traditional piano polyester finish
- Pros: This finish is a thinner coating applied directly to the high-quality wood, allowing the natural feel and integrity of the hard maple to shine through. It is described as 10 times harder than some polymer resins and very scratch-resistant.
- Authenticity: This finish evokes the feel of classic, old-fashioned tables.
- Criticism: The Polymer board plays slightly faster and more consistently. Every board is exactly the same, regardless of what wood was used for the butcher block.
-
Poured Polymer/Epoxy Finish: Most modern tables, including many imports and mid-range options, feature a thick, poured polymer or epoxy coating (often 1/8" or 1/4" thick)
- Pros: This durable synthetic material is highly scratch-, moisture-, and temperature-resistant, making maintenance easier.
- Purpose: The thick polymer layer creates a uniform surface that can minimize the impact of natural wood variation.
- Criticism: Purists argue that playing on a thick plastic layer undermines the authentic experience, as it is not actually on the wood surface.